GUM Member States Positivity Survey
The GUM Member States Positivity Survey (GUM-MSPS or MSPS) was a survey conducted by Zarel Smith from Statistic-Dime asking participants to rank full member states of the Grand Unified Micronational based on how positively said participant viewed them. It was held from 7–10 July 2020 in two instalments, the first from 7–8 July 2020 with 20 respondents, and the second from 9–10 July with a further 20 respondents, giving a total final of 40. The survey was Smith's eight survey (induing joint-ones). The ranking system was a scale of 1 to 5, similar to that of a Likert scale; 1 being not positive, and 5 being very positive. The top three highest scores were jointly New Eiffel, Posaf and Essexia (all with 4.2), while the lowest were Jupiter (2.7), Nemkhav Federation (2.9) and Hak'hanna and Hrafnarfjall (both 3.0). On the first survey, the results were New Eiffel (4.5), Posaf (4.4) and Essexia (4.3), while the lowest were Hrafnarfjall, Jupiter (both 2.8) and Juclandia (2.9).
Smith said that the survey was a large success "due to the fact that instead of asking participants to rank [micronations] by popularity, or development (which is always complete speculation of the participants), it was simply asking them to rank by their own opinion of how positively or well they viewed said nation, and thus the survey could not be inaccurate or incorrect."
The second full list includes all 42 member states, this time with 40 ratings on each one:
|Rank||Chg||Nation||Score (40)||Score (20)|
|T1||▬||New Eiffel||▼ 4.2||4.5|
|T1||▲ 1||Posaf||▼ 4.2||4.4|
|T1||▲ 2||Essexia||▼ 4.2||4.3|
|T5||▲ 7||Adammia||▲ 3.9||3.8|
|T5||▲ 2||Millania||▼ 3.9||4.0|
|T7||▼ 3||Lytera||▼ 3.8||4.1|
|T7||▼ 3||New Virginia||▼ 3.8||4.1|
|T10||▲ 6||Empire of Iustus||▲ 3.7||3.6|
|T10||▼ 1||Uber-Essian Union||▼ 3.7||3.9|
|T12||▼ 1||Wyvern||▼ 3.6||3.7|
|T12||▼ 3||Abeldane Empire||▼ 3.6||3.9|
|T12||▼ 3||Gymnasium State||▼ 3.6||3.9|
|T15||▼ 2||Aenopia||▼ 3.5||3.7|
|T15||▼ 2||Serene Beaconite Republic||▼ 3.5||3.7|
|T15||▲ 12||New Rizalia||▲ 3.5||3.3|
|T15||▲ 1||Zenrax||▼ 3.5||3.6|
|T15||▲ 5||Paravia||▬ 3.5||3.5|
|T15||▲ 5||Theodia||▬ 3.5||3.5|
|T15||▲ 9||Poplar Nerva||▲ 3.5||3.4|
|T22||▼ 6||Atovia||▼ 3.4||3.6|
|T22||▼ 2||Uskor||▼ 3.4||3.5|
|T22||▲ 2||Mercia||▬ 3.4||3.4|
|T25||▲ 2||Ashukovo||▬ 3.3||3.3|
|T25||▲ 14||Ikonia||▲ 3.3||3.1|
|T25||▲ 11||Plushunia||▲ 3.3||3.2|
|T28||▼ 12||Orientia||▼ 3.2||3.6|
|T28||▼ 8||Despotate of Vlasynia||▼ 3.2||3.5|
|T28||▼ 1||Jusin Republic||▼ 3.2||3.3|
|T28||▼ 1||Ledilia||▼ 3.2||3.3|
|T28||▲ 8||Swivia||▬ 3.2||3.2|
|T28||▼ 1||Nova-Occitania||▼ 3.2||3.3|
|T28||▼ 1||Sonderan||▼ 3.2||3.3|
|T35||▼ 11||Wegmat||▼ 3.1||3.4|
|T35||▼ 14||Caddia||▼ 3.1||3.3|
|T35||▼ 14||Nolland||▼ 3.1||3.3|
|T35||▲ 5||Juclandia||▲ 3.1||2.9|
|T39||▲ 2||Hrafnarfjall||▲ 3.0||2.8|
|T39||▼ 3||Hak'hanna||▼ 3.0||3.2|
|41||▼ 14||Nemkhav Federation||▼ 2.9||3.3|
|42||▼ 1||Jupiter||▼ 2.7||2.8|
The full list includes all 42 member states:
|T13||Serene Beaconite Republic||3.7|
|T16||Empire of Iustus||3.6|
|T20||Despotate of Vlasynia||3.5|
Style and method
Smith was inspired after finding out about a similar poll done in 2013 by the BBC, which asked participants to rank a select number of sixteen European countries based on how positively or negatively they viewed each one. Smith wanted to differentiate it from the 19th MicroWiki Influence Survey, which faced multiple criticisms on bias. In order to do this, Smith decided to select only GUM member states for the survey and require each participant to rank all forty-two member states. Smith hosted the survey on Google Forms as he usually does, and enabled IP address duplication checking. Two further questions were also on the survey, asking for the participant's name and nation. Smith set a goal of twenty respondents, finding it to be a large enough number for him. Smith's goal was reached within four hours, and thus the first survey concluded. After mild criticism for its short response time and small number of respondents, the survey was reopened between 9–10 July, with a further 20 respondents, giving a total of 40. The survey became Smith's third most partaken in.
Smith was inspired after finding out about a similar poll done in 2013 by the BBC, asking participants to rank a select number of sixteen European countries based on how positively or negatively they viewed each one. Smith had a set goal of twenty respondents. The survey was advertised in multiple Discord servers, mainly in the GUM server and MicroWiki@Discord. The survey began on 7 July at 20:24 (BST; UTC+1), and ended at 00:56 on 8 July the next day with the twentieth and final respondent. Smith hand counted and calculated the results and added it to a Google Doc, finally publishing it at 02:23. After mild criticism for its short response time and small number of respondents, the survey was reopened between 9–10 July, with a further 20 respondents, giving a total of 40. The survey became Smith's third most partaken in.
Smith worked out the following grades and colour schemes for each one in the first survey:
- 4.0 — Most positive (8 nations): Green
- 3.5 — Positive (15 nations): Black (default)
- 3.0 — Not positive (16 nations): Orange
- 2.5 — Most not positive (3 nations): Red
The top three were bronze, silver and gold respectively.
The second survey did not use this.
Findings and analysis
The survey found that positivity could be linked to said nation's delegation, as the top three nations, New Eiffel, (Zarel Smith), Posaf (Nicholas Randouler) and Essexia (Lord Matthew, Emperor Terry) all had frequent political turmoil, however despite this they were all seen positively. It also found that, as expected, the more active nations scored higher than less active ones in the MicroWiki Sector, such as nations like Jupiter, Juclandia and the Nemkhav Federation scoring Incredibly low. People also reported rating nations they had an "average" opinion on or did not know a 3.
Differences between the two surveys
According to Smith, the reason for the lowering of the majority of results was due to the calculation method: "If a nation received six 4s, and than received a 5, the score would be 4.1429; however, if it than received a 1, the score go down to 3.75. Another 5 would only bring the average up to a 3.8889 - lower ratings massively outweigh higher ratings, and as more people took the second survey, naturally the ratings went down." Another observation from Smith found that more members of the "old guard" took the second survey than the first, likely being (although by no means being the actual reason) because they are not as active on MicroWiki@Discord and more old guard members who took the survey are from the United Kingdom and the first survey was held during 20:24 to 00:56 BST. Smith said this could be linked to older nations (although not necessarily "old guard") like Juclandia, Hrafnarfjall and Adammia gaining ratings as opposed to losing them.
The survey was overall very positively received, though criticised for its short running time on the first one. After the second survey, it was generally received very positively. The survey was cited as an influence for two equivalent surveys looking at the Cupertino Alliance by Logan Ross in October and December 2020.