MicroWiki:Good articles/Nominations/Archive 4

From MicroWiki, the free micronational encyclopædia
Jump to navigation Jump to search
OverviewNominationsRevisitsArchivesFeaturedSummariesStatisticsList

January 2013

Grand Unified Micronational

Nominator:  Flatland  talk • contribs  Your friendly patroller and future best friend! 04:37, 26 June 2012 (GMT)

Prsänëan language

Nominator: ~Signed by: HRH James E Wilary I ( Grand Duchy of Prsänëa) 04:29, 28 July 2012 (GMT)

Currency

Nominator: ~Signed by: HRH James E Wilary I ( Grand Duchy of Prsänëa) 06:59, 22 September 2012 (GMT)

Bowie

Nominator: Pet Fluffy (Talk) 10:20, 17 December 2012 (GMT)

SBC TV

Nominator: ~Signed by: HRH James E Wilary I ( Grand Duchy of Prsänëa) 07:36, 2 January 2013 (GMT)
  • OPPOSE --Leon 19:10, 2 January 2013 (GMT)
  • OPPOSE Ciprian IJuclandia 00:17, 3 January 2013 (GMT)
  • OPPOSE --Hərpyer Akrıši Ovi (Rick) - talk • user 01:34, 3 January 2013 (GMT)
  • SUPPORT DA, the Siroccan Premier and owner of the Gas-Fired BantramTM. 08:42, 3 January 2013 (GMT)
  • OPPOSE BarnabyHands 12:04, 3 January 2013 (GMT)
  • GUYS - the GA process is not supposed to be a strawpoll (MW:NOTDEMOCRACY etc). When voting, state your reasons for doing so, especially if you oppose. The point of this process is not a majority vote but for people to scrutinise the articles and for the staff to them determine whether or not they should be included as a GA based on the discussions that are had. tl;dr version: don't just put 'support' or 'opppose' - state the reasons for your vote because that's the whole point of this process. Dr. Freeman (Talk • Contribs • Website) 22:32, 3 January 2013 (GMT)

Federal Commonwealth of Sirocco

Nominator: ~Signed by: HRH James E Wilary I ( Grand Duchy of Prsänëa) 07:40, 2 January 2013 (GMT)
  • SUPPORT --Leon 19:10, 2 January 2013 (GMT)
  • OPPOSE Ciprian IJuclandia 00:17, 3 January 2013 (GMT)
  • SUPPORT DA, the Siroccan Premier and owner of the Gas-Fired BantramTM. 08:42, 3 January 2013 (GMT)
  • SUPPORT --User:Demontux - Egtavian President and Evil Oppressive Webmaster of Doom 09:09, 3 January 2013 (GMT)
  • OPPOSE BarnabyHands 12:07, 3 January 2013 (GMT)
  • TENTATIVE SUPPORT Pretty good and generally meets the criteria, but I'd like to see the history section perhaps moved to its own article and a 1-2 paragraph summary on the main article, just to cut down on the visual effects of the large blocks of text in this section. Dr. Freeman (Talk • Contribs • Website) 22:36, 3 January 2013 (GMT)

National Centre of Computing (Sirocco)

Nominator: ~Signed by: HRH James E Wilary I ( Grand Duchy of Prsänëa) 07:42, 2 January 2013 (GMT)
  • SUPPORT --Leon 19:10, 2 January 2013 (GMT)
  • OPPOSE Ciprian IJuclandia 00:17, 3 January 2013 (GMT)
  • SUPPORT, it was designed with a GA in mind. DA, the Siroccan Premier and owner of the Gas-Fired BantramTM. 08:42, 3 January 2013 (GMT)
  • SUPPORT BarnabyHands 12:05, 3 January 2013 (GMT)
  • SUPPORT meets all the criteria well - the only one that's a bit iffy for me is the comprehensiveness of it, but I don't think that it's reasonable to expect more detail on such a topic. Besides, that would probably make it too long... Dr. Freeman (Talk • Contribs • Website) 22:45, 3 January 2013 (GMT)

Micro High

Nominator: ~Signed by: HRH James E Wilary I ( Grand Duchy of Prsänëa) 07:43, 2 January 2013 (GMT)
  • SUPPORT --Leon 19:10, 2 January 2013 (GMT)
  • OPPOSE Ciprian IJuclandia 00:17, 3 January 2013 (GMT)
  • SUPPORT DA, the Siroccan Premier and owner of the Gas-Fired BantramTM. 08:42, 3 January 2013 (GMT)
  • OPPOSE BarnabyHands 12:07, 3 January 2013 (GMT)

Alexander Reinhardt

Nominator: ~Signed by: HRH James E Wilary I ( Grand Duchy of Prsänëa) 07:53, 2 January 2013 (GMT)

Because we must appeal to our Italian overlords. ~Signed by: HRH James E Wilary I ( Grand Duchy of Prsänëa) 07:53, 2 January 2013 (GMT)

  • SUPPORT --Leon 19:10, 2 January 2013 (GMT)
  • OPPOSE Ciprian IJuclandia 00:17, 3 January 2013 (GMT)
  • SUPPORT -- User:Demontux - Egtavian President and Evil Oppressive Webmaster of Doom 08:18, 3 January 2013 (GMT)
  • SUPPORT DA, the Siroccan Premier and owner of the Gas-Fired BantramTM. 08:42, 3 January 2013 (GMT)
  • SUPPORT BarnabyHands 12:04, 3 January 2013 (GMT)

Empire of Austenasia

Nominator: ~Signed by: HRH James E Wilary I ( Grand Duchy of Prsänëa) 07:55, 2 January 2013 (GMT)

February 2013

Foreign relations of Indokistan

Nominator: ~Signed by: HRH James E Wilary I ( Grand Duchy of Prsänëa) 03:48, 2 February 2013 (GMT)
  • TENTATIVE SUPPORT: Just a few niggling grammar and spelling errors. Other than that it seems fine. DA, the Siroccan Premier and owner of the Gas-Fired BantramTM. 12:16, 2 February 2013 (GMT)
  • SUPPORT: Seems fairly detailed and well-written. --L.L. Simpson (bio  • talk) 12:40, 2 February 2013 (GMT)

Dale national football team

Nominator: ~Signed by: HRH James E Wilary I ( Grand Duchy of Prsänëa) 06:26, 2 February 2013 (GMT)
  • SUPPORT OPPOSE: Comprehensive and coherent enough, but as Leon said, Dale is defunct. DA, the Siroccan Premier and owner of the Gas-Fired BantramTM. 12:16, 2 February 2013 (GMT)
  • OPPOSE: Dale Republic is defunct, needs to be re-written to reflect that. --L.L. Simpson (bio  • talk) 12:40, 2 February 2013 (GMT)

Cizland

Nominator: ~Signed by: HRH James E Wilary I ( Grand Duchy of Prsänëa) 22:00, 2 February 2013 (GMT)
  • OPPOSE: There's not much to the article. More stuff should be added to it before making it a GA. DA • Atomic Age • Telegraph • BantramTM 04:54, 9 February 2013 (GMT)

Yablokogate

Nominator: DA • Atomic Age • Telegraph • BantramTM 22:34, 2 February 2013 (GMT)

2011 Intermicronational Summit

Nominator: DA • Atomic Age • Telegraph • BantramTM 22:34, 2 February 2013 (GMT)
  • COMMENT: the fact it's in "Cleanup" means little actually, since we don't have a standard for deciding when to denote articles as needing cleanup work. I cannot even tell why they placed the "outdated" template there, so it doesn't matter. If the article is good, that someone randomly put up a template at the top doesn't discourage me. ~Signed by: HRH James E Wilary I ( Grand Duchy of Prsänëa) 17:40, 3 February 2013 (GMT)
  • REJECTED ~Signed by: HRH James E Wilary I ( Grand Duchy of Prsänëa) 07:37, 9 February 2013 (GMT)

Inyo, Prsänëa

Nominator: ~Signed by: HRH James E Wilary I ( Grand Duchy of Prsänëa) 04:46, 3 February 2013 (GMT)

Organisation of Active Micronations

Nominator: ~Signed by: HRH James E Wilary I ( Grand Duchy of Prsänëa) 05:31, 3 February 2013 (GMT)

March 2013

Overturn GA status of Yablokogate

Nominator: Dr. Freeman (Talk • Contribs • Website) 10:31, 15 March 2013 (GMT)

I would like to make a strong case for the declassification of the Yablokogate article as a GA. It fails three criteria: 2, 3 and 4. It is not comprehensive. The article totally neglects to mention Aldrich's second response to the accusations levelled against him, which was a major part in this entire affair, given that the dossier authors removed their authorship (save for Bradley and Lethler). The 'Legacy' section, which should include quite a bit of information on its numerous effects on subsequent goings on, consists of a single sentence. The proposed commission section also needs work. For Criterion 3, there were neutrality disputes from the time it was written that were never resolved. See the article's talk page for more information. Same goes for Criterion 4. This article was well on the way to becoming one of the best articles on MicroWiki, but it still needs a heck of a lot of work. If anyone gets around to actually doing it one day, then it will become one of the best GAs that we have. Until then, it clearly fails on three out of the six criteria for a GA, so I would strongly commend this to everyone concerned.

Retrieved from "https://micronations.wiki/index.php?title=MicroWiki:Good_articles/Nominations/Archive_4&oldid=1765699"